New Year, New 3PL: How to Switch and Save

2025 Goals written on a notepad "Find a Better 3PL"

In This Article:

During the New Year, many individuals resolve to shed unnecessary things in their lives. Businesses should consider adopting a similar mindset, especially when it comes to logistics. The beginning of the year is a great time to evaluate your current Third-Party Logistics (3PL) provider and decide if it’s time for to switch 3PLs. Inefficiencies can hold back operations, affecting both costs and customer satisfaction. Ending a relationship with an underperforming 3PL is like making a New Year’s resolution—getting rid of the old and welcoming the new.

Understanding When It's Time to Switch Your 3PL Provider

Identifying when it’s time to switch your 3PL can significantly impact your operational efficiency and bottom line. The decision isn’t always straightforward, but several key indicators suggest it may be time to make a change.

Signs Indicating a Need for Change

  • Rising Costs: If you’re seeing consistent increases in logistics expenses with no corresponding improvement in service or technology, it might be time to evaluate alternatives. Look for hidden fees or surcharges that erode your profit margins. (Discover how to reduce logistics costs.)
  • Poor Service Levels: Delays in delivery, frequent errors, and lack of communication are red flags. A 3PL provider should enhance your customer satisfaction, not detract from it.
  • Limited Scalability: As your business grows, you need a logistics partner that can scale operations accordingly. Inflexibility in handling increased demand or new distribution channels is a clear sign to look elsewhere.
  • Lack of Technological Integration: In today’s market, seamless integration with ecommerce platforms and real-time tracking are non-negotiable. If your current 3PL lacks these capabilities, it could hinder your competitive edge.

Evaluating Current Performance Metrics Against Business Goals

To thoroughly assess whether a switch is necessary, conduct a detailed evaluation of your current 3PL’s performance metrics:

Accuracy Rates: Monitor the frequency of order inaccuracies or return rates due to fulfillment errors. High error rates are a sign of poor inventory management, and it directly affects customer satisfaction and profitability.

Cost Efficiency: Analyze cost per unit shipped and compare it with potential savings from alternative providers offering competitive rates without compromising service quality.

Customer Service: Gauge the responsiveness and effectiveness of your current provider’s customer support. Working with a 3PL with a call center with American agents and omnichannel customer solutions will ensure you meet the modern shopper’s high expectations.

Warehouse Management: Evaluate the accuracy and efficiency of your 3PL’s warehouse management system and order fulfillment processes. Inadequate handling can result in stockouts, delays, or incorrect shipments.

Delivery Times: Are deliveries consistently on schedule? Evaluate their on-time delivery rate against industry standards and your own benchmarks.

Incorporating these performance metrics into your evaluation will provide a comprehensive picture of your current 3PL’s strengths and weaknesses, aiding in the decision-making process for a potential switch.

Benefits of Switching Your 3PL Provider

Switching to a new 3PL provider can significantly impact your bottom line. Often, businesses find that their current providers fail to meet evolving needs, leading to inflated costs and inefficiencies. A strategic switch can reverse these trends, unlocking cost savings and boosting operational performance.

Cost Savings with a New 3PL Provider

  • Better Rates: By negotiating new contracts, you often secure more competitive rates on services that are crucial to your logistics operations. This includes reduced fees on warehousing, transportation, and additional value-added services.
  • Reduced Operational Expenses: A new provider might offer advanced technology solutions that streamline logistics management, thereby cutting unnecessary expenses. Integrations with existing systems can eliminate redundancies and automate processes, reducing labor costs.
  • Unique Value-Added Services: Some 3PL’s offer services, such as product personalization to help you boost average order values and improve your brand positioning. OWD offers personalized-to-consumer (P2C) fulfillment giving shoppers an easy way to personalized products with engravings, embroidery, personalized greeting cards, and direct-to-object printing.

Improved Efficiency Through 3PL Switch

  • Enhanced Operational Efficiency: Modern 3PL providers leverage cutting-edge technologies and data analytics to optimize supply chain processes. This ensures quicker turnaround times, from order processing to delivery, enhancing your service levels.
  • Error Reduction: Implementing robust tracking and inventory management systems minimizes errors in order fulfillment. Systems that offer real-time insights and predictive analytics allow you to anticipate issues before they arise, improving accuracy across the board. Integrating strategies like batch picking, kitting services, and warehouse picking strategies can also reduce errors and logistics expenses.

Transitioning to a new provider isn’t just about saving money; it’s about creating a more agile and responsive logistics framework. By partnering with a 3PL that aligns with your goals and values, you can streamline operations and enhance your brand reputation in the eyes of consumers.

Choosing the Right Type of 3PL Provider for Your Business Needs

Understanding the types of 3PL providers is crucial in aligning your logistics strategy with your business goals. As the New Year approaches, it’s time to shed any “dead weight” and ensure your 3PL partner is an asset, not a liability.

Types of 3PL Providers

Standard 3PL Providers: These are basic service providers offering fundamental logistics services like warehousing, transportation, and distribution. They suit businesses seeking straightforward fulfillment solutions without additional technological support.

Technology-focused 3PLs: These providers leverage cutting-edge technology to optimize supply chain operations. With advanced logistics software solutions, they offer real-time data analytics, order management systems, EDI integration, AI logistics solutions, lot management, and automated processes. Ideal for businesses that prioritize efficiency and demand integration with various ecommerce platforms.


Specialized 3PLs: Tailored for specific industries or unique service needs, specialized providers offer niche services such as cold storage for perishables, hazardous material handling, or personalized-to-consumer (P2C) fulfillment. They cater to businesses with distinct logistical requirements that go beyond standard operations.

Aligning with Your Business Needs

Selecting the right type of 3PL provider is pivotal for operational success and growth. Consider these factors:

  • Evaluate Your Requirements: Analyze your business’s specific logistics demands. Do you need advanced technological integrations, or are industry-specific services a priority?
  • Scalability: Choose a provider capable of scaling with your growth trajectory—whether you’re expanding domestically or globally.
  • Cost-Benefit Analysis: Weigh potential savings against service quality improvements to determine if a change would enhance profitability.

Breaking up with your current 3PL may seem daunting, yet aligning yourself with a partner who truly understands and supports your needs can be transformative. You could be missing out on advantages like a dedicated 3PL account manager, QVC shipping, peak season management, and multi-channel distribution.

Navigating the Transition Process to a New 3PL Provider

Switching to a new 3PL can be transformative, but it requires strategic planning to ensure a seamless transition. A well-executed transition minimizes disruptions and maintains service continuity while outsourcing fulfillment to the professionals.

Steps for a Smooth Transition

1. Comprehensive Needs Assessment

Start by evaluating your logistical requirements, identifying what your current provider lacks and what you aim to achieve with the new 3PL. This assessment forms the foundation of your transition strategy.

2. Transition Plan Development:

Develop a detailed plan that outlines each step of the transition process. Include timelines, responsibilities, and critical milestones to keep the process on track.

3. Stakeholder Engagement

Ensure all relevant stakeholders, including internal teams and key contacts from both the outgoing and incoming 3PL providers, are engaged early on. This collaboration facilitates a smoother handover of responsibilities.

4. Data Migration and Integration

Efficient data transfer is vital. Work closely with the new provider to ensure all inventory, order history, and customer data are accurately migrated to their systems. Leverage their integration capabilities for seamless connectivity with your existing ecommerce platforms.

5. Training and Onboarding

Familiarize your team with the new provider’s systems and processes through comprehensive training sessions. A well-informed team can effectively manage any operational changes this transition might bring.

6. Testing Phase

Implement a testing phase where select operations are trialed with the new 3PL setup. This phase helps identify potential issues before full-scale implementation, allowing for timely adjustments.

Maintaining Service Continuity

  • Dual Operations Period: During the transition, consider a period where both old and new providers operate simultaneously. This overlap prevents shipping delays and reduces risks associated with abrupt changes.
  • Clear Communication Channels: Establish robust communication channels between all parties involved in the transition. Regular updates can preemptively address issues that might arise.
  • Performance Monitoring: Continuously monitor performance metrics during and after the transition to ensure that service levels meet or exceed expectations.

By focusing on these steps, you safeguard against disruptions while paving the way for improved supply chain management with your new partner.

Asking the Right Questions: Evaluating Potential New 3PL Providers

Selecting a new 3PL provider is a critical decision that can significantly impact your operations. To ensure you choose a partner who aligns with your business goals, it’s essential to ask the right questions. These inquiries will help you gauge their capabilities and fit.

Key Questions to Consider:

Understanding a 3PL’s industry-specific experience helps predict their ability to handle your logistics challenges. Look for providers with a proven track record in domains similar to yours.

As your business grows, so will your logistics needs. Ensure the provider can scale operations efficiently without compromising service quality.

Seamless integration with your current ecommerce platforms, ERP systems, and other technologies is crucial for operational efficiency. A robust API offering or compatibility with existing systems can be a significant advantage.

Advanced tech capabilities such as real-time order tracking, inventory management dashboards, and reporting tools can enhance visibility and control over your logistics processes.

Delve into their policies on service disruptions and their strategies for maintaining continuity during unforeseen events.

Identify what specific fulfillment services they offer—be it custom packaging, international shipping, call center services, or personalized fulfillment options like OWD’s P2C services.

Request references or case studies from current clients to gain insights into their reliability and performance from an external perspective.

Transparency in pricing is crucial for budgeting accurately. Understand how costs are calculated—whether by size, weight, or delivery time—to avoid unexpected charges.

Enhancing Customer Experience Through Better Logistics Management with a New 3PL Provider

Changing your logistics provider can greatly improve your customer experience, similar to making a New Year’s resolution to eliminate inefficiencies. Efficient order fulfillment is key to this improvement, directly affecting shipping costs and delivery times. With a new 3PL provider offering advanced logistics solutions, you can ensure that products reach customers quickly and reliably, exceeding their expectations and building loyalty to your brand.

Impact on Shipping Costs and Delivery Times

Reduced Shipping Costs:

By partnering with a skilled 3PL provider, you can optimize shipping routes and take advantage of volume discounts, resulting in lower shipping costs. These savings can either be passed on to your customers or reinvested into your business operations.

Improved Delivery Times:

In the world of ecommerce, being timely is crucial. Selecting a 3PL provider known for its advanced technology and efficient processes will enable you to offer faster delivery times, delighting your customers and encouraging them to make repeat purchases. You can even start offering overnight shipping and achieve more sustainable fulfillment.

Customer-Centric Logistics Solutions

Personalized-to-Consumer (P2C) Fulfillment

OWD’s P2C services offer unique personalization options like engraving and embroidery, elevating the unboxing experience and opening a new profit center for your business. Customers value these personalized touches, increasing brand affinity and driving repeat purchases.

Transparency and Communication

Warehouse Manager working from a desk in a warehouse.A 3PL should provide real-time tracking capabilities, ensuring customers stay informed about their shipment status from the first to the last mile of delivery. They’ll also be equipped with a team of dedicated account managers who act as an extension of your team, assisting with resolving errors and optimizing the entire fulfillment process. This transparent communication builds trust and strengthens the relationship.

By resolving to break up with inefficient logistics providers this New Year, you set your business on a path toward enhanced customer experience and operational excellence. The right 3PL partner becomes an invaluable part of your team, delivering not just goods but exceptional value directly to your customers’ doors.

Looking to Make the Switch?

The New Year is a perfect time to reassess and shed inefficiencies, just like resolving to shred dead weight. Consider making a strategic switch if your current 3PL provider feels more like an anchor than a sail. Breaking up with your existing logistics partner might seem daunting, but the rewards—cost savings, enhanced operational efficiency, and improved customer experiences—are worth it.

Take the first step towards transformation by booking a consultation with OWD. Our expert team will work closely with you to provide tailored solutions that align with your business objectives. With our Personalized-to-Consumer (P2C) fulfillment services, you can turn what once was perceived as a cost into a profitable opportunity. Imagine offering your customers personalized engraving or embroidery at checkout, boosting their satisfaction while enhancing brand loyalty.

Why Choose OWD?

Our team of experts will work closely with you to understand your specific business needs. With our robust technology platform and extensive network of warehouses, we can offer you unparalleled speed and reliability in order fulfillment. Whether you’re a direct-to-consumer brand looking to expand globally or a B2B enterprise seeking streamlined operations, OWD has the expertise and resources to support your growth.

In This Article:

Subscribe to our Newsletter

Tincidunt urna mauris eu quam vulputate lobortis sit. Purus feugiat arcu nunc quisque massa ut.

Enter your email to subscribe 
to our newsletter *

Hubspot CTA Headline Goes Here and Here

New call-to-action

Related Articles

Are You Ready to Start Personalizing?

Personalized-to-Consumer (P2C) fulfillment gives e-commerce sellers the opportunity to transform the products they already sell into tailored experiences made for every customer. Our P2C services include engraving, embroidery, direct-to-object printing, and custom greeting cards.

Fulfillment Costs

Fulfillment costs are based on three criteria: size, weight and delivery time.

OWD offers five service levels: economy (7-10 days); Standard (5-7 days), 2-Day, Overnight and International.

Starting At

$3.99

Per Unit

FAQs

Donec ut ligula eu ante blandit congue pulvinar ut turpis.

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Ut elit tellus, luctus nec ullamcorper mattis, pulvinar dapibus leo.

Phasellus vehicula risus a libero placerat, quis ultrices velit tempus.

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Ut elit tellus, luctus nec ullamcorper mattis, pulvinar dapibus leo.

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit.

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Ut elit tellus, luctus nec ullamcorper mattis, pulvinar dapibus leo.

Cras tempus augue eget dictum aliquam.

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Ut elit tellus, luctus nec ullamcorper mattis, pulvinar dapibus leo.

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit.

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Ut elit tellus, luctus nec ullamcorper mattis, pulvinar dapibus leo.

International Shipping

The old way to ship internationally

DDU means Delivery Duty Unpaid – where the buyer pays for all of the import fees at delivery.

Unexpected import fees give buyers sticker shock – not good. When they refuse to pay, you’ve lost a sale and must pay to return your product, or abandon it.

DDU is an old idea whose time has passed. For these reasons and more, OWD doesn’t recommend DDU for e-com sellers.

The best way to ship internationally

DDP is an acronym for Delivery Duty Paid. DDP means that the seller pays for all the duties and import fees.

With DDP, your customers won’t be surprised with unexpected customs charges – good!

With OWD’s landed cost calculator, your foreign customers will know exactly what their various VAT, customers and duties will cost. No unhappy surprises.

Ship flat-rate anywhere in the world starting at:

$16.39

One World Direct, B.V.

For large-scale operations needing a full solution in Europe, there’s OWD Europe, based in Amsterdam.

We Make Contact Center EASY

Sell More with Live Agents

The Services

OWD handles phone calls, e-mails and web chat eighteen hours a day from our own state-of-the-art facility.

We’ll handle your inbound sales and customer service contacts.

You get career agents who speak American English and know how to sell.

The Costs

$99 gets you 200 calls, e-mails or chats handled every week.

You get your own phone number and custom e-mail.

We do a lot more. Call for details.

More than a Call Center

Get Virtual Assistants as needed

One World’s contact center in Mobridge, South Dakota.

The Voice of Your Brand

We Make Returns EASY

Returns? Yuck.
One World has a simple solution.

All-Inclusive Returns

OWD’s all-inclusive Returns service provides simplicity and high-end customer service. OWD includes a pre-printed return label as part of your packing slip. Your customer need only drop it in the mail.

What’s included: packaging slip with return label, QC inspection, re-bag, re-tag and return to stock. What’s excluded: postage cost, poly bags and any special packaging.

Base Price

$4.95

Add-On Services

Call For Quotes